Skip to content

BEHIND THE SCENES: Newmarket students give board failing grade over Pride flag decision

NewmarketToday reporter Joseph Quigley takes us behind the scenes

Numerous students staged a walkout at Sacred Heart Catholic School to protest the school board's decision not to fly a Pride flag. Joining a coordinated walkout across York Catholic District School Board high schools on June 8, the students voiced their opposition to the board's vote against displaying the flag, following months of debate on 2SLGBTQIA+ issues. Student trustee Jonah James commended the students' action, emphasizing their right to recognition, acceptance, and love.

The school board's decision not to fly the Pride flag has faced widespread criticism, with many students, community members, and the teachers union expressing their disagreement. The 6-4 vote against the flag raised concerns among some trustees about its symbolism. In addition to the flag controversy, the school's LGBTQ+ support group had their posters torn down, further exacerbating the situation. Student Stella Almeida expressed how hurtful the board's decision was, particularly for a community that has endured past pain and sought support.

The student-led march garnered support from community members and union officials. Attendees, such as OPSEU Local 330 President Kelly Martin and York Region Children's Aid Society union president Andrew Harrigan, emphasized the importance of solidarity and creating a safe environment for all students. The York Catholic Teachers released a statement backing the protest and called on the trustees to rectify their failure by raising the Pride flag. Community member Ann Monks voiced her support, urging the students to continue their protests until meaningful change is achieved. Although students do not have a vote at the board of trustees, student trustee Jonah James expressed hope that their persistence would eventually bring about change.

The students' walkout highlights their determination to advocate for inclusivity and acceptance within their school community. They seek to challenge the board's decision and foster an environment where all students can embrace their identities without fear. Their ongoing efforts serve as a testament to their resilience and commitment to achieving a more inclusive and supportive school environment.

Video Summary:

The York Catholic District School Board is facing criticism for its refusal to fly the Pride flag at its headquarters in Aurora. Opponents of raising the flag argued that it could symbolize more than acceptance, raising concerns from some within the Archdiocese of Toronto who do not accept same-sex marriage. Some trustees also expressed skepticism about the flag's ability to address issues like bullying and discrimination in schools. However, widespread condemnation of the board's decision has come from politicians and pride groups, with politicians from various parties speaking out against the decision and showing support for the LGBTQ+ community.

Other school boards in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) have taken a different approach to this issue. Most public school boards in the GTA, including the Toronto District School Board, have chosen to fly the Pride flag in support of LGBTQ+ students and communities. While Catholic boards have typically followed the stance of their archdiocese, some have made the decision to fly the flag despite opposition. The province requires school boards to show support for LGBTQ+ students and communities, but it does not specifically mandate the display of a Pride flag.

The refusal to raise the Pride flag by the York Catholic District School Board has generated significant attention and sparked widespread discussions about inclusivity and support for the LGBTQ+ community. The contrasting approaches taken by different school boards highlight the divergent perspectives and actions within the educational system regarding LGBTQ+ issues.